Safe and effective weight loss BMI: is it the be all and end all? August 28 2019
Lisa Cugnetto Lisa Cugnetto Journalist

How do you measure health? We look at body mass index (BMI) and some other indicators of your health status.

Your body mass index is calculated by dividing your weight in kilograms by your height in metres squared. 

“Typically we say a healthy BMI is between 18.5–24.9kg/m2,” explains Bupa dietitian Rosalyn D’Angelo. She notes however that an individual’s BMI isn’t always an accurate representation of their weight or health.
The World Health Organization began using BMI in 1995. For 20 years, health experts believed that it was possible to estimate health risks by whether or not a patient had a healthy BMI. But BMI tends to overestimate obesity among shorter people and underestimate it among taller people. Therefore, D’Angelo explains, BMI shouldn’t be used as a guide for adults who are very short (less than 150cm) or very tall (more than 190cm).
“What the BMI equation does not look at is body composition, or body shape. We say that BMI is an approximate measure of your total body fat – and it is better used on a population level – not to assess an individual,” says D’Angelo.
“We know that muscle is very heavy and many elite athletes who carry more muscle than your average adult would be classified as ‘obese’ by the BMI equation, but we know that they are probably not at risk of obesity-related chronic diseases.”
It can also be an inaccurate measure for pregnant women, children, and older people. For some ethnic groups, including people of Asian, Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander descent, the range that indicates a healthy body mass index may need to be adjusted. The calculation may also be flawed by failing to account for gender, because the ideal healthy BMI for men and women may be different, as men generally have more muscle mass than women. 

A different measure

The body mass index formula isn’t a singular measure of your health. You may need to consider other lifestyle changes even if your BMI falls in the healthy range. 

“Your waist circumference is a strong predictor of your health risk,” offers D’Angelo and  complements your BMI score.
She explains that the fat we carry around our hips and thighs is ‘subcutaneous fat’ (the fat that sits just below the skin), whereas the fat around the waist is called ‘visceral fat’ and stores around our vital organs, such as our pancreas, stomach and intestines.
“This visceral fat doesn’t just sit there,” says D’Angelo. “We call it ‘metabolically active’ as it releases nasties called ‘cytokines’ that cause inflammation. We know that excess fat around the waist can increase your cholesterol levels, blood sugar levels and blood pressure. This in turn can increase your risk of chronic diseases such as type 2 diabetes and heart disease.”
She advises men should aim for a waist circumference of less than 94cm and women of less than 80cm. Men with a waist circumference above 102cm and women who are above 88cm have a substantially greater risk.

Healthy living equipment

Beyond BMI

It’s easy to become alarmed if a BMI calculator states that you are outside the healthy range. However, there are other factors to consider. 

“It is important to look beyond your BMI and also ‘know your numbers’,” says D’Angelo. “There are healthy ranges set for a range of different risk factors for chronic disease.” 

She lists the following as risk factors for cardiovascular disease in addition to BMI: 

You can get different indications of your cholesterol from  a fasting cholesterol test including: 

  • Total cholesterol
  • HDL ‘good’ cholesterol
  • LDL ‘bad’ cholesterol
  • Triglycerides. 

If you have a family history of heart disease it is especially important that you know your cholesterol levels. 

Diet and lifestyle changes can improve cholesterol levels, but they are also influenced by genetics. So find out what you can do to help keep your levels in a healthy range by having a chat with your GP. 
Blood glucose levels

Glucose is a type of sugar. Your body uses glucose as fuel for energy, with a hormone called insulin helping cells to take in glucose from your blood. When your body is resistant to the action of insulin, or if it can’t make enough insulin, you can get high levels of glucose remaining in your blood. 

There are tests to check your blood glucose levels in a fasting state and the results can be an indicator of having or developing type 2 diabetes. Ideal glucose levels are  less than  5.5 mmol/L while fasting. If yours is above this range, you may need further testing to see if you may have diabetes.

Blood pressure 

Optimal blood pressure is generally less than 120/80. People with high blood pressure often don’t have any symptoms, but may be at higher risk of heart disease and other chronic health problems. So it’s important to know what your blood pressure is, and, if it’s high, have a chat with your doctor about what you can do to lower it.

While diet and lifestyle habits can affect blood pressure, so can stress and underlying medical conditions.  Interestingly, many people’s blood pressure can go up at the doctor’s because they’re anxious. We call this ‘white coat hypertension’. A 24-hour blood pressure monitor can give you a clearer picture of what’s really going on with your blood pressure, if your doctor wants to know more.

Health care providers will usually take two or more readings before diagnosing a patient with high blood pressure (above 140/90). They may recommend other tests to see if there are other health problems that might be causing or affecting blood pressure. 

Aim for a healthy weight

The body mass index formula isn’t perfect, but it can indicate that you need to lose weight. 

“Excess weight can affect you in many ways such as worsening the symptoms of asthma, increasing your risk of sleep apnoea, and the extra weight can put extra pressure on your joints,” says D’Angelo. “So even if all your blood test results are within range, there are still plenty of reasons to ensure you’re a healthy weight.”

D’Angelo notes the importance of staying in touch with your GP throughout life: “Don’t just go to the doctor when you get sick. Get your screening tests done. A blood test only takes a few minutes. Prevention is much better than cure.”

Mature woman riding bicycle Safe and effective weight loss Why have I put weight on around the middle? Have you always carried what’s (not so) lovingly dubbed the ‘spare tyre’ or found you’re putting on weight in the middle later in life? Tracy McBeth Tracy McBeth Journalist A woman eating a burger Safe and effective weight loss The important role of emotions in weight loss How you feel could have as much to do with weight loss as diet and exercise. Here’s how to create the right mindset to achieve your goals. Angela Tufvesson Angela Tufvesson Journalist A woman comparing food labels Safe and effective weight loss Orthorexia: taking healthy eating to the extreme We look at the new term 'orthorexia', coined to describe an obsession with certain so-called ‘healthy’ diets, which, in some cases, can lead to nutritional deficiencies or even malnutrition. Debbie Elkind Debbie Elkind Journalist
Back To Top
Lisa Cugnetto Lisa Cugnetto Journalist Lisa has worked in various roles across print and digital media, marketing, communications, publishing and content marketing for over 10 years. Based in Sydney, she writes across all manner of subjects, but she loves writing about lifestyle, health, popular culture, innovation, arts and design.